$2,100,000
Updated a year ago
Sold

86 Crooke Ave

Prospect Park South, Brooklyn | Saint Pauls Place & Crooke Ave

11 Rooms7 Beds3 Baths1,870 Square FeetSingle Family

$2,100,000
floors / apts2 / 1
Lot Size32'x100'
Built Size24'x41'
ZoneR6B
Building TypeHouse
RE Taxes$7,776
Price Per SF
$1,123

This property was sold for $2,100,000 on 04/22/25.

Outdoor space and views

  • Backyard
  • Porch

Building Amenities

  • Driveway
  • Garage
  • Garden
  • Laundry Room

Property Description for 86 Crooke Ave

86 Crooke Avenue is the best house in the best location on a block that you never even knew existed in Prospect Park South. Just a stone's throw from Prospect Park, and steps to theB/Q subway lines at the Parkside station, with a shared driveway and private garage. This fully detached home is a richly designed one-family Victorian property with 5 beds, 4.5 baths, and elegant proportions on four floors. Enjoy light from four exposures, a homey front porch, and fantastic shopping in every direction, in addition to world-class amenities including the Brooklyn Botanic Gardens and the Brooklyn Museum. Walking your dog or taking a run in the park will be a daily breeze when all you have to do is make your way down one short block to the park entrance.
Find yourself a world away from the bustle of urban life in a historic home with a Mid-century inspired interior that offers warmth, luxury and whimsy at every turn. Enter through a gracefully preserved archway into a Great Room complete with a formal dining room, a stately living room with a jaw-dropping Cle' tiled decorative fireplace, and a grand chef's kitchen. Sliding glass doors lead you to a spacious garden AND parking area in the rear. And don't miss an elegant wet bar with custom designer lighting, marble shelving, and wine fridge. Custom cabinetry with unlaquered brass hardware have been designed with practicality and storage in mind, and Quartz countertops offer immense prep space with the added beauty of a marble mosaic backsplash AND a unique reeded window backsplash that brings in light. Appliances include a vented SMEG 6-burner GAS range and a Fisher and Paykel paneled fridge. A discrete powder room has been beautifully appointed with verdant green tiles and a Calacatta Violetta countertop.
Head up the sweeping staircase to a 2nd floor complete with primary suite, 2 additional beds, and a 2nd full bath. Leafy green street views await from the primary where you can indulge your desire for a king-sized bed and a walk-in closet fit for a king. The accompanying bath is a dream with marble topped double vanity and custom storage. A glass-enclosed walk-in shower offers 2 showerheads and custom storage niches to hold all your toiletries. Cream ceramic tiles and a jaw-dropping terrazzo floor are a dreamy combo. The 2nd bath on this floor offers a calming and earthy combination of classic penny tile and dreamy Tundra Gray marble floors. The custom walnut vanity won't disappoint. Fixtures include a suite of enchanting aged-bronze cross handles fixtures, showerheads and hand showers, the perfect accompaniment to the modern classic interiors seen throughout.
The top floor includes two additional light-filled bedrooms, an abundance of storage closets, a large laundry room, and a third full bathroom. This third full bath includes a generous soaking tub with a unique bird's eye view of the yard while also affording privacy for your luxurious soaks. The laundry room is quite impressive too with its tiled floors and walls and oversized side-by-side LG washer and dryer. What could have just been a utilitarian room has been transformed into our favorite room in the house! The bedrooms on this floor share impressive views and unexpected and sizable storage areas neatly tucked away. The kids can enjoy their very own floor, or use this level for offices, guest rooms, or even playrooms, art studios or music rooms. And if this isn't enough, head back all the way down to a windowed and finished English basement where you will enjoy a loft-like space with high ceilings and natural light.
An absolutely breathtaking fa ade, porch and roof have all been restored and designed to perfection in addition to beautiful hardwood floors, all new heating and cooling systems, new windows, plumbing, sewer lines and electric. The suite of custom lighting throughout illuminates every room in a warm glow, no matter the time of day, or the season. This is a home that you MUST see in person to believe.

Listing History for 86 Crooke Ave

Now
04/22/2025
$2,100,000
Sold and Closed by Deborah L. Rieders
Corcoran
02/07/2025
Contract Signed by Deborah L. Rieders
Corcoran

Building Details for 86 Crooke Ave

OwnershipSingle Family
Building TypeHouse
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1910
Floors/Apts2/1
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

Church Av
0.14 miles
Parkside Av
0.2 miles

Citi Bike

Caton Ave & St. Pauls Pl
0.07 miles
Ocean Ave & Crooke Ave
0.07 miles

Contact Agents

Contact Agents

Albi Zhubi
Corcoran
Sarah Shuken
Corcoran

Prospect Park South | Brooklyn

Quick Profile

Charming tree-lined blocks, grand homes, and grassy center esplanades - Prospect Park South feels more like a quiet suburb than Brooklyn, the most populated borough in New York City. 

The small landmarked neighborhood in south Brooklyn is bounded by Coney Island Avenue to the southwest, Ocean Avenue to the northeast, Prospect Park to the south, and Beverly Road to the south. 

Don’t let the suburban vibe of Prospect Park South fool you, urban grit awaits you just outside the neighborhood's boundaries. It’s about a 45-minute commute to Manhattan on the B, Q, or F train or a short walk to livelier neighborhoods. Prospect Park South is flanked by Windsor Terrace, Kensington, Ditmas Park, and Flatbush. It’s the best of both worlds. 

The history of the neighborhood starts with its original developer, Dean Alvord. If it wasn’t for his unique vision, Prospect Park South may have never blossomed into what it is today. In 1899 Alvord wanted to take advantage of Brooklyn’s newly created railway system that connected the borough. He purchased farmland and began building the neighborhood, which began as a six-block-by-two-block swatch of land with grand homes. Many of the houses were Victorian-inspired. Alvord marketed the neighborhood as a slice of country in the big city and the rest is pretty much history. 

Prospect Park South is a few blocks bigger these days. Its grand Victorian-style homes still define the neighborhood. Other architectural styles found in the nabe include Colonial, French Revival, and Spanish Mission. Apartments and a few prewar co-ops complete the neighborhood's housing stock. 

There aren’t too many places to shop in Prospect Park South but you might find a few spots in the commercial areas along Coney Island Avenue and Church Avenue. The suburban setting of Prospect Park South is popular with young families, which is why they’ve flocked there for the last decade.

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 77018TH