$1,998,000
Updated a year ago
Sold

12 Middlemay Circle

Forest Hills Gardens, Queens | Bye Street & Bye Street

9 Rooms4 Beds3.5 Baths2,714 Square FeetSingle Family

$1,998,000
floors / apts2 / 1
Lot Size60'x121'
Built Size42'x20'
ZoneR3-2
Building TypeHouse
RE Taxes$8,952
Price Per SF
$736

This property was sold for $1,835,000 on 06/02/25.

Outdoor space and views

  • Backyard
  • Patio
  • Porch

Building Amenities

  • Driveway
  • Garage

Property Description for 12 Middlemay Circle

Welcome to 12 Middlemay Circle-a captivating semi-attached Tudor nestled on one of the most picturesque streets in Forest Hills Gardens. Exuding timeless charm and character, this residence greets you with a charming covered front porch that overlooks a tranquil circular park, offering a perfect blend of beauty and serenity. Upon entering, you're greeted by a cozy living room with built in cabinetry and a wood-burning fireplace. Adjacent is a bright and airy sunroom with original clay tile flooring, providing a wonderful spot to soak in the afternoon light. The formal dining room, complete with china cabinet, offers an elegant setting for hosting gatherings and large dinner parties. The sun-filled kitchen boasts white cabinetry, ample natural light, and direct access to a delightful outdoor patio above the garage-a delightful spot for morning coffee or alfresco dining. The second floor features a spacious primary bedroom with a full ensuite bath, alongside two additional bedrooms that share a full hall bath. On the third floor, you'll discover a charming fourth bedroom with an additional full bath with claw foot tub as well as a cedar closet and attic space ripe with potential either as an additional bedroom or home office. The possibilities continue with the expansive unfinished basement, which includes a half bath and laundry and offers limitless opportunities for customization, whether you envision a recreation room or gym, the possibilities are endless. Outside, you'll be greeted by beautiful front, side, and rear gardens, offering a peaceful setting for outdoor enjoyment. The private backyard retreat provides space for relaxation or entertaining. Additionally, a one-car garage, conveniently accessible from the common driveway, adds practicality to this charming home. Located in the heart of Forest Hills Gardens, this home provides unbeatable access to Station Square, the LIRR, and various transit options, making commuting a breeze. Indulge in upscale shopping, dining, and charming boutiques along Austin Street and Metropolitan Avenue, while enjoying world-class recreation at the nearby West Side Tennis Club. Offering the perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, this property presents a rare opportunity to own a truly exceptional home in one of Forest Hills Gardens' most sought-after locations.


Listing History for 12 Middlemay Circle

Now
06/02/2025
$1,835,000
Sold and Closed by Rachel Borut
Douglas Elliman
04/17/2025
Contract Signed by Rachel Borut
Douglas Elliman

Building Details for 12 Middlemay Circle

OwnershipSingle Family
Building TypeHouse
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1935
Floors/Apts2/1
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

Forest Hills-71 Av
0.26 miles
75 Av
0.32 miles

Railroad

Forest HillsLong Island Rail Road
0.13 miles

Citi Bike

Austin St & 70 Rd
0.21 miles
Queens Blvd N & 72 Rd
0.22 miles

Contact Agent

Contact Agent

Rachel Borut
Douglas Elliman
All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 98065TH