$1,888,888 $1,899,999
Updated 6 days ago
Price drop

5 East 124th Street

East Harlem, Manhattan | Fifth Ave & Madison Ave

13 Rooms8 Beds8 Baths3,840 Square FeetIncome Property

$1,888,888 $1,899,999
floors / apts5 / 8
Lot Size20'x100'10"
ZoneR6A
Building TypeTownhouse
RE Taxes$14,661
Price Per SF
$492

Outdoor space and views

  • Backyard

Building Amenities

  • Voice Intercom
  • Garden

Property Description for 5 East 124th Street

Cap Rate Potential Over 7%

Prime Investment Opportunity Overlooking Marcus Garvey Park - A Rare Multi-Family Brownstone in a Transforming Harlem

5 East 124th Street presents a once-in-a-generation opportunity to own a true Harlem brownstone on a landmarked, park-facing block, with built-in long-term upside in one of Manhattan's most rapidly appreciating neighborhoods.

Located directly across from Marcus Garvey Park, this four-story, 8-unit brownstone offers a front-row seat to Harlem's ongoing renaissance. Investors and owner-occupiers alike will benefit from the property's unmatched combination of location, scale, and long-term potential-where protected zoning ensures the park's open southern light and historic charm remain unchanged forever.

Investment Highlights
  • 6 Rent-Stabilized Units - Immediate income with future upside
  • 2 Vacant Units at Closing - Ideal for owner-occupancy or value-add opportunities
  • 5 Renovated Units - Providing modern convenience while maintaining pre-war charm
  • Strong Rent Roll with room to grow ($180K+) & over 7% Cap Rate - Excellent cash flow in an appreciating market
  • Low Annual Taxes ($11K) - Favorable holding costs enhance long-term profitability
Historic Brownstone, Modernized for Today

Built in 1909, this classic Harlem brownstone retains its pre-war details while featuring modern renovations (2017). The true 4-story brownstone sits on a 20' x 100.92' lot and is built 20' x 48', offering approximately 3,840 SF of livable space.

For buyers looking to combine investment with luxury living, the parlor-level unit offers a private backyard, while the top-floor penthouse boasts iconic park views-perfect for an end-user or high-end rental.

The Neighborhood: Unstoppable Growth & Unmatched Lifestyle

This coveted landmarked district is experiencing major development while maintaining the timeless charm of Harlem's most historic streetscape. Just steps from Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, and top-tier dining, the property is also within easy reach of major transportation hubs:

  • 2 Blocks to 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Subway Lines
  • 3 Minutes to Metro-North
  • Quick Access to Columbia University, Upper East & West Sides, and Midtown
Why Harlem? Why Now?

Harlem has emerged as a top destination for long-term real estate appreciation, with rising property values, luxury developments, and a cultural revival that makes it one of NYC's most exciting investment markets. With limited housing inventory on this protected historic park block, 5 East 124th Street stands out as a rare acquisition for investors seeking both immediate returns and long-term value growth.

This is not just an investment-it's a chance to own a piece of Harlem's history with guaranteed long-term upside in an area where demand is surging, but supply remains limited.

Seize this opportunity to invest in one of Manhattan's most storied and evolving neighborhoods.

Contact us today for a private tour of this one-of-a-kind Harlem brownstone!


Video Walkthrough


Listing History for 5 East 124th Street

Now
04/29/2025
$1,888,888 [-$11,111] [0.6%]
Price Drop by John Santulli
Douglas Elliman
04/25/2025
$1,899,999 [-$50,001] [2.6%]
Price Drop by John Santulli
Douglas Elliman

Building Details for 5 East 124th Street

OwnershipIncome Property
Building TypeTownhouse
Service LevelVoice Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1909
Floors/Apts5/8
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

125 St
0.23 miles
125 St
0.26 miles
116 St
0.47 miles
116 St
0.49 miles

Railroad

Harlem-125 StMetro-North Railroad
0.16 miles

Citi Bike

5 Ave & W 126 St
0.11 miles
Park Ave & E 124 St
0.15 miles

East Harlem | Manhattan

Quick Profile

Take a stroll through East Harlem and you’ll find a vibrant, culturally diverse neighborhood, which is evident no matter which direction you look. East Harlem is also known as Spanish Harlem, El Barrio, and “The Neighborhood,” as it is home to a population that represents Hispanic immigrants, primarily from Puerto Rico, as well as from Mexico, Cuba, and the Dominican Republic. These immigrants brought their cultures with them, in the form of music, dance, art, and food. During the day, you’ll find the neighborhood filled with opportunities to experience Latin culture. Both the salsa dance craze and the graffiti style of art were born right in East Harlem. There are many great places to sample authentic cuisine, from Rao’s (where you cannot get a table unless you inherit one, and any reservations must be booked years in advance) to sidewalk carts, where you can get the best “street meat” to be had in NYC.

In East Harlem you’ll find a number of innovative educational opportunities in the form of specialized and charter schools that are considered top-notch. Many of these have very competitive admissions criteria and offer curricula that focus on creativity and social awareness. Such schools are a draw for young families that want to raise their children in an educational system that goes above and beyond the standard.

The vibe of East Harlem is one of community and neighbors that interact with each other routinely. There are many small, family-owned and -operated businesses and restaurants that have been neighborhood anchors for years. As you stroll through East Harlem, you will be immersed in sights, sounds and flavors that are straight from Latin American or the Caribbean islands, sometimes both at once. You can sample Puerto Rican-inspired plantain mofongo, which is mashed plantains with garlic and pork rinds, from local sidewalk carts. Or if it is a hot summer’s day, you might enjoy a Mexican-inspired licuado, which is a blended drink similar to a smoothie, made with milk, fruit, and ice. Sometimes, spices, citrus juices, and sugar are added. Although you will find an abundance of authentic cuisine and music no matter where you look in East Harlem.

Prefer to cook at home? East River Plaza offers Target, Costco, and Aldi stores, all of which offer fresh food at reasonable prices.

East Harlem housing consists of more affordable walk-ups, low-rise pre-war buildings, brownstones, and is dominated housing complexes. You can find some comparatively large apartments at reasonable price points, and even some rent-stabilized apartments. Luxury co-op and condo units are being built on the southern boundary of East Harlem. 

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 73880TH