$2,500,000
Updated a year ago
Sold

46 Sherman Street

Windsor Terrace, Brooklyn | 10th Ave & 11th Ave

15 Rooms4 Beds3 Baths2,783 Square FeetMulti-Family

$2,500,000
floors / apts3 / 2
Lot Size19'x105'
Built Size19'x47'
ZoneR5B
Building TypeHouse
RE Taxes$10,130
Price Per SF
$898

This property was sold for $2,828,000 on 07/07/25.

Outdoor space and views

  • Backyard
  • Frontyard
  • Patio

Building Amenities

  • Garden

Property Description for 46 Sherman Street

Exceptional Bayfront Limestone with Details Galore Airy rooms and extravagant detail combine to make this stunning, carefully preserved three-story limestone on the south side of Sherman Street a unique opportunity for discerning buyers. The charming bayfront facade is outstanding both for its striking exterior design and the abundant light it provides. Totaling 2,783 square feet, this four bedroom, three bathroom 1901 home is one of the most intact you will find. Optimally located on desirable Sherman Street mid-way between 10th and 11th Avenues, the mature tree canopies and consistent rows of low-rise residences bring together this exceptional and friendly serene community. Standing at a generous 19.75’ wide and 47’ deep on a 105’ long lot, 46 Sherman Street is currently used as a two-family with an owner’s sprawling lower duplex and the entire spacious top floor as an income-producing rental apartment. Delivered vacant, it is easily adapted as a one-family residence. Owned by the same family for nearly 40 years, the home has been well-cared for, evidenced by the impressive overall solid condition and many recent upgrades such as a new furnace, rear facade restoration, well-insulated wooden windows, and forward-looking, environmentally and economically-friendly solar panels that reduce electric bills to a bare minimum. The basement is dry with 8 ft ceilings. Period details and millwork are impressive and include many original built-ins on each floor: wooden bookcases with glass panes, pier mirrors, including one with entryway bench, three beautiful wood and ceramic-tiled fireplace mantels, spectacular wall moldings, parquet oak floors with inlay designs, fretwork, working pocket doors, stained glass skylight over the top floor staircase, a floor to ceiling wooden serving station, unique and lovely decorative wood relief wall panels, delicate plaster ceiling medallions, crown molding shelves, decorative plaster trim, and original wooden doors and closets throughout. The owner’s duplex is currently configured on the garden level with an eat-in country kitchen and front sitting room with harmonious dimensions, thoughtfully outfitted with custom-made, nature-inspired William Morris wallpaper. In the middle of the floor is a large, walk-in pantry and full bathroom. Above the garden level, is the classic triple parlor with sweeping 10 ft ceilings, an artist studio, office, and sizable bedroom. Off of the hallway is a second bedroom, bathroom, and additional closets. Moving to the top floor where period details have also been preserved, is a floor through apartment ready to rent or to be incorporated into the new owner’s space. Some photos have been virtually enhanced. Windsor Terrace’s small town feel offers many eclectic restaurants, cafés, bars, and boutiques including newly relocated Ladybird Bakery, and close proximity to Brooklyn’s Olmsted and Vaux’s masterpiece, Prospect Park, (with its 585 acres of open green space, wooded trails, waterfalls, lake and dog pond), BRIC’s summer performing arts at the Lena Horne bandshell, cycling and running lanes, and the revered Farmer’s Markets at Bartel Pritchard Square and Grand Army Plaza. The 46 Sherman Street location is ideal, bordering historic Park Slope and access to several bus lines and the trains at the Prospect Park Southwest Circle. Citi Bike locations are conveniently dotted throughout the area. Seize this rare opportunity to live in one of Brooklyn’s quintessential historic and extraordinary townhouses.

Listing History for 46 Sherman Street

Now
07/09/2025
$2,828,000
Sold and Closed by Anthony (Tony) Fanning
Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
03/13/2025
Contract Signed by Anthony (Tony) Fanning
Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

Building Details for 46 Sherman Street

OwnershipMulti-Family
Building TypeHouse
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1901
Floors/Apts3/2
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

15 St-Prospect Park
0.24 miles
Fort Hamilton Pkwy
0.46 miles

Citi Bike

11 Ave & Prospect Ave
0.07 miles
Prospect Park SW & 16 St
0.19 miles

Contact Agent

Contact Agent

Anthony (Tony) Fanning
Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

Windsor Terrace | Brooklyn

Quick Profile

The tiny, comma-shaped neighborhood of Windsor Terrace is bookended between two of Brooklyn’s largest green spaces, Prospect Park and the massive Green-Wood cemetery. Aside from the presence of the Prospect Park Expressway, which dissects the neighborhood in two, this residential community offers a suburban sensibility with its tree-lined streets, low volume traffic and the low height character of its streetscape.  

Many homes in the area are low to the ground, lending a suburban feel to the neighborhood, and the area has been down-zoned to maintain its low-rise appeal and character. There are plentiful brick row houses that have very low turnover. If you are lucky enough to buy or rent one, you tend to hold on to it. There are also small apartment buildings, private homes, condos and multi-family homes in a wide price range

There is commercial development along Prospect Park West, Fort Hamilton Parkway and Prospect Avenue, but even these new stores and restaurants are mostly family-owned and operated, maintaining the small-town charm. The pace of life is slower. The schools are good, which is a big draw for families with young children. The people are friendly, which gives a real sense of neighborhood and community to Windsor Terrace.

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 99305TH