Updated 9 hours ago

842 Carroll Street

Park Slope, Brooklyn | 8th Ave & Prospect Park West

20 Rooms12 Beds6.5 Baths7,098 Square FeetMulti-Family

$14,750,000
floors / apts5 / 2
Lot Size32'x74'
Built Size32'x50'
ZoneR7B
Building TypeTownhouse
RE Taxes$22,884
Price Per SF
$2,078

Listing Features

  • High Ceilings
  • Moldings
  • Original Details
  • Restored Details
  • Skylights
  • WBFP

Outdoor space and views

  • Backyard [32'x27']
  • Frontyard [32'x9']
  • Garden
  • Terrace

Building Amenities

  • Alarm System
  • Garden
  • Laundry Room

Property Description for 842 Carroll Street

Spectacular, one of a kind 32-ft+ wide mansion with unrivaled original detail set on bucolic Carroll Street just moments to Prospect Park. Built by famed architect C.P.H. Gilbert in 1887 at the height of the Gilded Age in America, this Romanesque Revival architectural masterpiece features the fine detailing and opulence that Gilbert was famous for. This unique residence is one of just a handful of grand houses in the area that is over 32-ft wide, and one of the only of this breadth that maintains the original footprint and original intact detail. The current owners are just the 4th family to own the home since 1887 when George Kenyon commissioned the house. With 12 bedrooms, 6 full bathrooms and 3 half baths this grand property spans over 7000sf of interior space with an additional 1280sf of outdoor space for a staggering 8400 in total. The garden is a separate renovated two-bedroom, two-bathroom guest apartment boasting a wall of triple sliding doors leading to a large backyard. Ascend the stoop to the jewel of the house at the grand parlor level, where the expansive entry area features a massive mahogany fireplace, a grand center staircase, and powder room. Oversized windows flood the dining room and extra wide south-facing living room with natural sunshine all day long. Original wood-burning fireplaces can be found in each room and is the centerpiece of the grand living room. The kitchen has brand new, never-used appliances and a south facing window-clad seating area that is set amongst the lush trees of the back yard. Up one flight you’ll find four sunny bedrooms, three fireplaces, and two full bathrooms. The primary bedroom suite features a south-facing deck and an enormous primary bathroom. The fourth floor has an additional 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, laundry room, and two fireplaces. The reinforced center staircase allows for a perfect layout with bathrooms in the middle and spacious rooms all around, bringing in the utmost sunshine into each of the bedrooms. The fifth floor is a spectacular, separate two-bedroom loft apartment showcasing vaulted 12-ft ceilings, original beams, a fireplace, full kitchen, 1.5 bathrooms, laundry, balcony, and 2 skylights. It evokes the feeling of a Parisian atelier and would be an ideal staff residence, artist’s loft, or guest suite. The present owner has gutted the house twice providing meticulously restored internal upgrades so that the infrastructure is of the highest quality:
  • Central A/C
  • 9 working fireplaces
  • New electric: extra large capacity electric risers with all 2 gauge distribution
  • 1-2 electric panels on every floor and heavily wired throughout
  • All new brass and copper plumbing with extra heavy cast iron
  • All original plaster replaced with skim coated walls
  • Main kitchen’s dishwasher, oven, stove and refrigerator have never been used
  • The staircase from parlor to 5th floor has been rebuilt
  • The rear kitchen extension is constructed of high strength steel and encased in mahogany and copper exterior
  • The rear living room bay was totally rebuilt and is mahogany and copper clad
  • The garden guest unit is completely insulated from the upper main
  • New boiler less than 5 years old
  • Alarm system installed
  • Original restored detail intact

    The grandeur and graceful lifestyle this spectacular house affords ensures that it will be handed down through generations. Set on one of the prettiest park blocks in all of Brooklyn, this trophy home is truly a must see. An opportunity for the most discerning buyer.


  • Listing History for 842 Carroll Street

    Now
    02/26/2025
    Back on the Market by
    Compass
    01/27/2025
    TOM by
    Compass

    Building Details for 842 Carroll Street

    OwnershipMulti-Family
    Building TypeTownhouse
    AgePre-War
    AccessWalk-up
    Year Built1887
    Floors/Apts5/2
    Learn More About the Building

    Transit and Citi Bike

    Subway

    Grand Army Plaza
    0.26 miles
    7 Av
    0.37 miles
    Eastern Pkwy-Brooklyn Museum
    0.47 miles

    Citi Bike

    Garfield Pl & 8 Ave
    0.09 miles
    Grand Army Plaza & Plaza St West
    0.15 miles

    Park Slope | Brooklyn

    Quick Profile

    Boasting beautiful tree-lined streets, brownstones and a range of activities for all age groups, Park Slope is consistently ranked as one of New York’s most desirable neighborhoods. Filled with lush parks and greenery, the neighborhood is also known for its rare combination of excellent public schools, award-winning restaurants, nightlife, small independently owned businesses and community gardens.

    Situated at the western slope of Prospect Park, the neighborhood is divided into different sections: North Slope, Center Slope and South Slope. Depending on who you ask, of course, the definitions of where these borders end and begin may vary (is the divide between North and Center deemed Union Street, Garfield Place, 1st Street or 3rd Street? The one between Center and South 6th Street, 9th Street, 11th Street or 15th Street?). 

    Regardless of what part of the Slope you find yourself on, there’s no shortage of architectural beauty. From row houses to brownstones to mansions, the idyllic setting of the neighborhood is further enhanced by its Romanesque and Renaissance Revival styles. Case in point of this is also two of the area’s most well-known churches, Park Slope United Methodist Church and Saint Augustine Roman Catholic Church. 

    Revered for its family-friendly appeal, Park Slope is often regarded as one of the best places to raise a family in New York City. That said, it doesn’t mean that parents don’t know how to have a good time... a slew of bars constantly opening in the neighborhood ranging from the high-end cocktail saloon to the dive (well, by Park Slope standards, anyway). 

    All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
    OLR ID: 94324TH