$4,995,000
Updated 3 months ago
Off Market

95-03/07 Cresskill Place

Jamaica, Queens | 95th Ave & 97th Ave

28 Rooms12 Beds8 Baths6,258 Square FeetIncome Property

$4,995,000
floors / apts2 / 8
Building TypeLow-Rise
RE Taxes$20,400
Price Per SF
$798

Building Amenities

  • Voice Intercom

Property Description for 95-03/07 Cresskill Place

9503 & 9507 Cresskill Place Jamaica, Queens

8 Free Market Units 2 Buildings Zoning Upside Strong In-Place Income Two adjacent four-unit buildings offered as a package in a quiet, residential pocket of Jamaica, Queens. This well-maintained, income-producing portfolio includes 8 free market residential units-delivered occupied-great for long-term stability, future repositioning, or redevelopment.

9503 Cresskill Place
Features four units ranging from approx. 597-723 sq ft with a mix of one- and two-bedroom layouts. Units include windowed kitchens, generous living areas, and ample in-unit storage.

9507 Cresskill Place
Four additional units including layouts up to 1,163 sq ft. Select residences feature oversized living rooms, dedicated dining areas, and multiple exposures. One unit spans nearly 40 feet across, offering townhouse-style proportions. The properties have been well maintained and held by long-term ownership. Current rent roll available upon request.

Zoning: R5A Lot Size: 5,250 sq ft
Zoning allows for an additional two stories of development with potential to expand to just over 10,806 buildable square feet (confirm all details with an architect).

Downtown Jamaica is a vibrant hub in Queens, known for its bustling retail district, diverse shopping, and strong sense of community. From major retailers to local businesses, the area offers everything you need-and more. York College anchors the south side with a tree-lined campus, ample parking, and great public transit access. Residents enjoy nearby museums, parks, fitness centers, and movie theaters. The LIRR and multiple subway lines make commuting to Manhattan and beyond fast and convenient. With ongoing high-rise development, Downtown Jamaica is on the rise as a dynamic place to live, work, and explore.

This is a rare opportunity to acquire two turnkey, free market assets with existing cash flow and clear upside in a rapidly growing pocket of Queens. Shown by appointment only.

Listing History for 95-03/07 Cresskill Place

Now
05/26/2026
TOM by Ivan Mijalkovic
Corcoran
01/20/2026
$4,995,000 [-$1,705,000] [25.4%]
Price Drop by Ivan Mijalkovic
Corcoran

Building Details for 95-03/07 Cresskill Place

OwnershipIncome Property
Building TypeLow-Rise
Service LevelVoice Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1931
Floors/Apts2/8
Learn More About the Building

Contact Agents

Contact Agents

Licensed As
Ivan Mijalkovic
Associate Broker
License#:
10301211186
Company:
Corcoran
Licensed As
Lauren Renee Bennett
Associate Broker
License#:
10301212820
Company:
Corcoran

Jamaica | Queens

Quick Profile

Jamaica Queens is buzzing. Although it doesn’t have the same level of excitement or sensory overload that Times Square imparts on its visitors, it’s a bustling city center just brimming with activity. The courts, government offices, hospitals, colleges, ethnic restaurants of every kind, big box retailers and mom-and-pop shops – the neighborhood has a lot going on at any given moment.

 Jamaica, a diversely populated middle-class neighborhood located in southeastern Queens has a huge commercial and retail district with a residential component too. Its boundaries are Hillside Avenue to the northwest, Van Wyck Expressway to the south, Linden Boulevard to the southeast, and 188th Street and Jamaica Boulevard to the northeast.

 Jamaica has a similar history to other areas of Queens and Manhattan. Indigenous tribes called it home until the Dutch arrived in the mid-1600s. They purchased the land for a very small amount (history says two rifles, a fur coat, and some gun powder). Dutch Governor Peter Stuyvesant named it Rustdorp, which translates to rest town. English colonists took over the lands from the Dutch around 1655 and changed the name to Jamaica.

 In the late 1770s, Jamaica became a popular trading post and it was eventually incorporated into a village in 1814. In 1834, B and J Railway Company built a train line connecting Brooklyn to Jamaica. It didn’t last long because B and J Railway ran out of money to keep the trains operational. New investors stepped in and saved the company. They renamed the organization the Long Island Rail Road Company.

 In 1898, Queens became part of New York City and served as the county seat for Manhattan.

 Today’s Jamaica has a thriving business district that represents the diversity of Queens. West Indian grocery stores, African American bath and beauty supplies, South American eateries, Indian owned electronic stores, Italian grocers, South East Asian markets line the streets selling their goods and services.

 There are even green spaces in this densely populated urban neighborhood. Rufus King Park, Marconi Park, Jamaica Playground, Saint Albans Park and Baisley Pond Park are just a few of the more notable ones.  

 Jamaica is accessible with plenty of transportation options. Jump on the Long Island Railroad and be in Manhattan in 35 minutes, or head the other direction to Montauk or the Hamptons. The Air Train takes you to John F. Kennedy International Airport. Subway and bus lines will whisk you to Manhattan, Brooklyn, or further into Queens.

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 100402TH