$2,750,000
Updated a year ago
Sold

84 Rogers Ave

Crown Heights, Brooklyn | Park Place & Prospect Place

10 Rooms4 Beds2.5 Baths3,024 Square FeetMixed Use

$2,750,000
floors / apts3 / 2
Lot Size18'x79'
Built Size18'x55'
ZoneR6A
Building TypeTownhouse
RE Taxes$4,656
Price Per SF
$909

This property was sold for $2,750,000 on 07/31/25.

Outdoor space and views

  • Garden

Building Amenities

  • Voice Intercom
  • Garden

Property Description for 84 Rogers Ave

Super special opportunity for an end-user, investor, artist, musician, restauranter, or future gallerist to own a former historic church in Crown Heights, very close to the border of Prospect Heights, Clinton Hill and Bed-Stuy. Formerly used as a house of worship on a quiet strip of Rogers Avenue, at the hub of four amazing neighborhoods, this unique property has been masterfully transformed into a loft-like commercial space on the first floor with soaring ceilings, and two high-income producing renovated sun-filled apartments on the upper two floors. This exceptional slice of architectural history is just waiting for its new owner to determine its next best use after undergoing a thorough restoration by its current owner. A clean and dry basement also has windows and a walk-out to the garden, expanding greatly the possible uses for the ground floor commercial space. Upgrades are extensive and include a new Certificate of Occupancy allowing for restaurant use in the commercial space, plus all new plumbing, roof, kitchens, baths, water line, intercom system, central heating AND cooling in every unit, and 200 AMP electrical service. The garden has also been beautifully hardscaped and includes unique design touches like the repositioning of a decorative marble mantle, making it as cozy as it practical, and ready just in time for summer.

Enter through a fully restored solid brass and pastel stained-glass double door in front for the commercial space, and an arched wood door on the side to access the residential spaces. All doors and windows on the first floor have retained their original arches and trace mullions, stained and fluted glass detailing, and iron work. Enter through these dramatic doors into a truly unexpected and voluminous commercial space that offers the best of the old and the new. Stylish and durable poured concrete floors live in tandem with 12" ceilings, designer lighting, and custom marmorino plastered walls and ceilings that lend a dramatic chiaroscuro feeling to the space. Enjoy a light filled space in front, a stylish powder room with rare pink American Standard fixtures and a full prep kitchen in the center, and then an additional room in back with perfect flow to the garden. The professional kitchen includes a turbo convention oven, low boy fridges, professional metal shelving, and an induction oven if you are an aspiring restauranteur, and is being offered separately for sale. A Cippolino marble countertop and bar is a show-stopper. The space is even "sound system" ready with pre-wiring already in the walls. The windowed full basement is the perfect complement to this space offering clean and dry storage, easy garden access, and a powder room.

The two upper floors make a wonderful home for an end-user, high-income rentals for an investor, or some combination of both. Units include Mitsubishi ducted heat pump heating and cooling systems, new kitchens and baths, and flexible layouts. Stylish Forbo floors add a whimsical touch and make maintenance a breeze. The 2nd floor is an oversized one-bedroom apartment with the option to convert it to a two-bedroom for higher income. The top floor is a two bedroom with the option for a three-bed conversion. Both units feature spacious renovated kitchens with walnut cabinetry, black Caesarstone countertops, undermount sinks, stainless streel appliances, and their own full-size and vented washers and dryers. Bathrooms have been newly transformed with Terra Cotta tile and designer fixtures. Rent these units as-is, or combine both floors into a large owner's duplex, flooded with light, and live above your work space!

The turnkey nature of this property, combined with its unique historical references and perfect location at the crossroads of 4 brownstone neighborhoods, make this a winning purchase for investors and end-users alike. Low taxes make this a cheaper opportunity than any of the surrounding condos, and offer space to really spread out and live your best life. Showings by appointment only. Delivered vacant.

Listing History for 84 Rogers Ave

Now
07/31/2025
$2,750,000
Sold and Closed by Deborah L. Rieders
Corcoran
06/16/2025
Contract Signed by Deborah L. Rieders
Corcoran

Building Details for 84 Rogers Ave

OwnershipMixed Use
Building TypeTownhouse
Service LevelVoice Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1910
Floors/Apts3/2
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

Park Pl
0.24 miles
Nostrand Av
0.31 miles
Franklin Av-Medgar Evers College
0.34 miles
Botanic Garden
0.4 miles
President St-Medgar Evers College
0.43 miles

Railroad

Nostrand AvenueLong Island Rail Road
0.41 miles

Citi Bike

Sterling Pl & Bedford Ave
0.1 miles
Prospect Pl & Nostrand Ave
0.15 miles

Contact Agent

Contact Agent

Crown Heights | Brooklyn

Quick Profile

Originally known as Crown Hill by the Lenape Indians that lived there, Crown Heights has evolved into a diverse neighborhood, occupied primarily by Hasidic Jews and one of the largest Caribbean populations to be found anywhere outside of the West Indies. 

Head over to Nostrand Avenue, one of the main West Indian commercial areas in the neighborhood, which is lined with stores that have been in those exact same places for generations, providing their goods and services to area residents. Kingston Avenue has similar commercial activities that support the Jewish community, and Franklin Avenue shows the most signs of change and gentrification, with an ever-expanding mix of yoga studios, coffee shops, and organic grocery stores that serve the influx of young professionals. No matter which of these areas you visit, you will find an interesting mix of businesses that you wouldn’t normally picture as existing side-by-side. It is all part of the cultural diversity of Crown Heights.

The neighborhood is bisected, from east to west, by Eastern Parkway, which is a beautiful, 3-mile-long boulevard lined with mature trees. This leafy oasis was designed by Frederick Law Olmsted, famed designer of Central Park, the Biltmore Estate in North Carolina, and the U. S. Capitol in Washington, D. C.

You will find a mix of low-rise apartment buildings, large middle-class elevator buildings, brownstones, and some luxury buildings. Century-old architecture stands next to modern residential developments in a visually interesting mix of styles, much as the diversity of the residents exists. People who would not normally meet and mix are forging new pathways to cultural understanding by working, living, and playing together in the same neighborhood.

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 69643TH