$4,200,000
Updated 8 months ago
Sold

158 President Street

Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn | Henry Street & Hicks Street

12 Rooms6 Beds4.5 Baths3,600 Square FeetMulti-Family

$4,200,000
floors / apts4 / 4
Lot Size20'x100'
Built Size20'x40'
ZoneR6B
Building TypeTownhouse
RE Taxes$19,056
Price Per SF
$1,167

This property was sold for $4,200,000 on 12/17/25.

Listing Features

  • Gas Heat

Outdoor space and views

  • Garden [20'x39']

Building Amenities

  • Voice Intercom
  • Laundry Room

Property Description for 158 President Street

This Carroll Gardens townhouse is situated on a 100' lot, built 20x50 on the first 2 floors, and 20x40 on the upper floors.. This smart investment is currently used as 3 family home, with a 4 family certificate of occupancy. All of the hard work is done. A beautifully designed dream home dedicated for the owner, plus two valuable investment apartments. A parlor & garden duplex plus rec room for the owner. The two market rate high income investment apartments are ready for occupancy.

All of the hard work is done and this Brooklyn Townhouse is ready to go! Including high quality split air-conditioning systems in each unit, renovated kitchen and bathrooms. A high quality home and low maintenance.

For the Owner: Parlor and Garden Duplex plus finished recreation room & Garden. The modern renovations blend with the historic charm; high level craftsmanship, quality fixtures, simplicity and taste

This beautifully designed space blends Historic charm with modern functionality and industrial accents. The parlor floor has ceilings over 11'. Crown moldings, hardwood maple floors, and exposed brick are just some of the features on this main level. Perfectly appointed closet and storage space, an office/guest room, and a half bath are all on the parlor floor. The kitchen is situated in the extension.

The gourmet kitchen is located on the parlor floor extension, open to the living space, and overlooks the garden. The kitchen is fully equipped with high-quality stainless-steel appliances including a top of the line range with vent hood, multiple pantries and cabinet space. Cabinet- matching dishwasher and oversized refrigerator. The kitchen is thoughtfully located for direct access to the customized deck, and into the beautifully landscaped garden. More about the garden later.

An impressive solid maple hardwood staircase leads to the garden floor. There is also direct access under the stoop through a well-designed mudroom to the garden floor to keep organized.

The garden floor has 2 spacious bedrooms plus a large center home office/den between the 2 bedrooms. This middle room has separate access from the hallway. The master suite overlooks the garden and has direct access to the garden. Convenient walk-in closet plus plenty of storage and closet space, and a private bathroom. Both bathrooms on the garden floor have high quality materials and designer fixtures.

The cellar has been transformed into a multiuse recreation space. In addition to the recreation area, there is a laundry room, plenty of storage, and space to set up a home workshop. Elevate Summer Festivities all year long with a Gorgeous Landscape. This urban garden was designed for and built to maximize outdoor living, dining, and entertaining. The sun filled garden, hardscaped and low maintenance, will keep your home clean with plenty of space around the perimeter to grow plants and ivy. The hoop stays.

Investment income:
2nd floor apartment: This highly desirable apartment is configured as a 1 bedroom plus den. Hardwood floors, exposed brick walls, tin ceilings, charming fret work and French doors. Split central air conditioning system.

3rd floor apartment: An even more desirable apartment offers 1 bedroom plus den plus mezzanine loft for a flexible layout. The apartment has a high quality split air-conditioning system and a washer/dryer.

This home is ready to move right in, and immediately collect income from the rental apartments. Or convert to a single-family home now, or in the future.
A warm and wonderful home in the neighborhood that will make you feel right at home. The exciting new shops and restaurants compliment the local businesses that have been thriving for generations. An ideal setting to create traditions for years to come.

Listing History for 158 President Street

Now
12/17/2025
$4,200,000
Sold and Closed by Brian Lehner
Brown Harris Stevens
11/18/2025
Contract Signed by Brian Lehner
Brown Harris Stevens

Building Details for 158 President Street

OwnershipMulti-Family
Building TypeTownhouse
Service LevelVoice Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1900
Floors/Apts4/4
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

Carroll St
0.35 miles

Citi Bike

President St & Henry St
0.04 miles
Carroll St & Columbia St
0.14 miles

Contact Agent

Contact Agent

Brian Lehner
Brown Harris Stevens

Carroll Gardens | Brooklyn

Quick Profile

Filled with charming churches, whose ringing bells punctuate the days, together with quirky boutiques, trendy bars, Italian bakeries, and restaurants featuring a wide variety of cuisines, with an emphasis on traditional Italian cuisine, Carroll Gardens maintains a sense of Old World charm. While most of the restaurants are small and family-owned, there are Michelin-rated restaurants for those special date nights. Abundant coffee shops and bakeries ensure you are never far from a tasty pastry and your next cup of joe.

Unlike many neighborhoods, Carroll Gardens has an impressive array of grocery stores, including the popular Court Street Grocers. While Carroll Park is the main green space, located in the heart of the neighborhood, there are other parks, such as the Brooklyn Bridge Park, Cadman Plaza Park, and Van Voorhees Playground, all within easy walking distance.

Court and Smith Streets are the main commercial areas, packed with bakeries, intimate bars, unique boutiques, and small mom-and-pop Italian cafes, many with sidewalk or patio seating. Court Street has most of the older businesses that have operated for generations in the same location. Smith Street has more trendy establishments. 

If you are looking for a neighborhood that is quieter and less congested, Carroll Gardens might be a perfect fit. It is a great place to raise a family, with good schools and safe streets. It is the type of place where you will know the names of your neighbors and the owners of the shops and restaurants you frequent. It is a great walkable neighborhood for retirees, and an easy commute into the city for young professionals. The streets are shady and tree-lined, and many feature brownstones and townhouses that sport sizeable front gardens, adding to the natural charm of the neighborhood. 

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 22260TH