$670,000
Updated 3 months ago
Off Market

444 East 58th Street, 5-C

Sutton Place, Manhattan | First Ave & Sutton Place

4 Rooms2 Beds1 BathCo-op

$670,000
Maintenance$1,482

Listing Features

  • Corner Apartment
  • High Ceilings [9.5']
  • Moldings
  • Walk-in Closet
  • Washer / Dryer
  • New Windows
  • Dishwasher
  • Gourmet Kitchen
  • Open Kitchen
  • Windowed Kitchen

Outdoor space and views

  • City Views
  • East River
  • East Exposure
  • North Exposure
  • South Exposure
  • West Exposure

Building Amenities

  • Video Intercom
  • Alarm System
  • Elevator
  • Laundry Room

Policies

  • No Pets
  • Pieds A Terre Ok

Property Description for 444 East 58th Street, 5-C

Bright Prewar 2-Bedroom with In-Unit Washer/Dryer in Sutton Place

Welcome to this sun-filled and beautifully maintained two-bedroom, one-bath co-op on the northern tip of Sutton Place, where timeless prewar charm meets modern convenience. This inviting home features a rare grandfathered-in washer/dryer combo, offering the comfort and practicality of in-unit laundry, an exceptional find in a prewar building.

The windowed open-concept kitchen is ideal for both cooking and entertaining, complete with a breakfast bar, Bosch range, dishwasher, and ample cabinetry. The spacious living area is bathed in natural light, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Both bedrooms are well proportioned, and a large walk-in closet located off the hallway provides exceptional storage. Throughout the home, high ceilings, hardwood floors, and elegant prewar moldings add enduring character.

The building itself is impeccably maintained and features a stunningly renovated lobby that beautifully reflects the elegance and craftsmanship of the era in which the building was constructed, combining period details with a refined, contemporary sensibility. Additional amenities include an elevator, video intercom system, and a basement with card-operated laundry. Cats are welcome, though dogs are not permitted. Ownership policies are exceptionally flexible, with co-purchasing, parents buying for children, gifting, pied-à-terres, and subletting all allowed with board approval.

Perfectly located near the East River Esplanade, residents enjoy easy access to Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, Equinox, Bloomingdale's, and a vibrant mix of new restaurants and cafés. Experience classic Sutton Place serenity with the best of Midtown East just moments from your door.

All showings and open houses are by appointment. Please contact to schedule.


Listing History for 444 East 58th Street, 5-C

Now
05/16/2026
Expired by Josh Rubin
Douglas Elliman
05/04/2026
Back on the Market by Josh Rubin
Douglas Elliman

Building Details for 444 East 58th Street

OwnershipCo-op
Building TypeLow-Rise
Service LevelVideo Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessElevator
Year Built1920
Financing Allowed80%
Floors/Apts6/26
Learn More About the Building

Transit and Citi Bike

Subway

Lexington Av/53 St
0.41 miles
Lexington Av/59 St
0.43 miles
59 St
0.45 miles
Lexington Av/63 St
0.5 miles

Citi Bike

E 58 St & 1 Ave (NE Corner)
0.06 miles
E 58 St & 1 Ave (NW Corner)
0.08 miles

Contact Agent

Contact Agent

Josh Rubin
Douglas Elliman

Sutton Place | Manhattan

Quick Profile

Sutton Place is usually described with favorable words like charming, cozy, great neighborhood, hidden gem, sanctuary, or even small village inside a big city. Those descriptions aren’t from real estate folks either, they’re from the people that live and work there, so it must be true.

The quiet and upscale neighborhood is more like an enclave. It’s bounded by East 53rd Street to the south, East 59th Street to the North, First Avenue to the west, and the East River to the east. Most residents will tell you that everything you’ll ever need is located in the neighborhood. When it’s time to venture out into the cityscape, Sutton Place is within easy reach to Midtown and cultural attractions like the Museum of Modern Art, Rockefeller Center, Central Park and other iconic sites.   

Manhattan has always had notable celebrity residents. But for unknown reasons, Sutton Place has had more than its share of superstars over the years. Some of the more iconic celebs include: Marilyn Monroe and Arthur Miller, Freddie Mercury, Sigourney Weaver, Joan Crawford, Michael Jackson and sister Latoya (Just for one summer).

Sutton Place is named after Effingham B. Sutton, a shipping merchant and entrepreneur. After hitting it big in the California gold rush, Sutton built brownstones along East 57th and East 58th streets with aspirations of making the section more residential. Poverty and crime dashed his dreams. The street gangs that hung out along the dead-ends and cul-de-sacs added to the neighborhood’s decay. Sutton was about to give up on his development endeavors but the Vanderbilt’s and the Morgan’s showed up in the 1920s and transformed the neighborhood. It soon became a wealthy enclave.

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 1171831