$1,699,999
Updated 5 months ago
Off Market

1256 Bay Street

Rosebank, Staten Island | Scarboro Ave & Maryland Ave

4,590 Square FeetMixed Use

$1,699,999
floors / apts3 / 3
Lot Size30'x100'
Built Size30'x42'
ZoneR3A
Building TypeLow-Rise
RE Taxes$9,197
Price Per SF
$370

Building Amenities

  • Voice Intercom

Property Description for 1256 Bay Street

Located along Staten Islands '' Bay Street Corridor'' the proximity to Brooklyn and NYC is impeccable. Steps from your front door lands you at bus service to Brooklyn and Staten Island ferry. Minutes to train station. Seconds to restaurants and cafe's nightlife couldn't be any closer. Not only is this Legally 3 unit building fully renovated its delivered vacant! Boasting over 4500 sq feet not including the full basement. Currently zoned R3A with C1-2 overlay this allows for additional expansion of 1400sq ft consult with your architect. 2 Loft style apartments feature 10ft ceilings hardwood floors 3 bedrooms and well configured layouts. Storefront is ideal for Urgent care, Starbucks, Grocery store, Gym, Boutique, Supply house, the possibilities go on. Basement can produce additional revenue for storage or office suites. Large yard completes the space making this a smart investment with a potential of 8-10 pct. cap rate. Start your investment journey right here. MLS Approve- No financial provided due to the property being vacant.

Listing History for 1256 Bay Street

Now
04/01/2026
POM by Francis Shearon
Robert DeFalco Realty
02/06/2026
$1,699,999 [-$70,000] [4%]
Price Drop by Francis Shearon
Robert DeFalco Realty

Building Details for 1256 Bay Street

OwnershipMixed Use
Building TypeLow-Rise
Service LevelVoice Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1931
Floors/Apts3/3
Learn More About the Building

Contact Agent

Contact Agent

Francis Shearon
Robert DeFalco Realty
All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 103640TH