Updated 3 hours ago
New this week
557 Carlton Ave, 1
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn | Bergen Ave & Dean Street
5 Rooms2 Beds2 Baths2,200 Square FeetRental Property
$9,500
Lease Term12-12 Months
AvailableNow
Rent Per SF
$52
Listing Features
- Architectural Dtls
- Crown Moldings
- Exposed Brick
- Moldings
- Recessed Lighting
- Triplex
- Washer / Dryer
- Oversized Windows
- Dishwasher
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Open Kitchen
- S Steel Appliances
- Windowed Kitchen
- Powder Room
Outdoor space and views
- Garden
- East Exposure
- West Exposure
Building Amenities
- Voice Intercom
Policies
- No Dogs. Cats Allowed.
Property Description for 557 Carlton Ave, 1
Experience the elegance and grandeur of classic Brooklyn brownstone living at 557 Carlton Avenue. Set across three beautifully proportioned levels of an intimate two-family residence, this expansive two-bedroom, two-bathroom triplex seamlessly blends historic architectural character, generous living spaces, and a lush private garden sanctuary in the heart of Prospect Heights.
Dating to the early 20th century, the residence is a celebration of Brooklyn's architectural heritage. Exquisite original woodwork, intricate parquet and hardwood floors, soaring ceilings, elaborate crown moldings, decorative ceiling medallions, and beautifully preserved millwork create an atmosphere of timeless sophistication. Graceful archways, substantial wooden doors, and richly detailed banisters reflect the craftsmanship of a bygone era.
The parlor level showcases the home's most remarkable period details, featuring two generously proportioned bedrooms positioned at the front and rear of the residence. One is distinguished by an exquisite decorative fireplace with an ornate mantel, while both offer beautiful natural light, substantial wood-trimmed doorways, and original architectural detailing.
The garden level features an inviting front-facing living room and an exceptionally spacious, rear-facing eat-in kitchen designed for everyday comfort and entertaining. Highlights include stainless steel appliances, a dishwasher, custom wine storage, abundant cabinetry, and a striking wall of original wood built-ins with glass-fronted display cabinets. Beautifully patterned tile flooring adds character, while a full bathroom with a bathtub completes this level.
Beyond the kitchen awaits a true urban oasis: a private landscaped garden framed by mature greenery, charming brick pavers, and thoughtfully arranged plantings. Perfect for alfresco dining, morning coffee, or quiet relaxation, this enchanting outdoor retreat offers a rare sense of tranquility in the heart of Brooklyn.
The fully finished lower level provides an exceptional extension of the home's usable space, ideal for a media lounge, recreation area, home gym, or creative workspace. Built-in shelving, additional storage, an in-unit washer and dryer, and a second full bathroom with a stand-up shower complete this versatile level.
Situated along one of Prospect Heights' quintessential brownstone-lined blocks, 557 Carlton Avenue offers exceptional access to Brooklyn's most celebrated destinations. Barclays Center and Atlantic Terminal are moments away, while Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, and Crown Heights offer an abundance of acclaimed restaurants, cafés, and boutiques. Prospect Park, Grand Army Plaza, the Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Public Library's landmark Central Library are all nearby.
An extraordinary combination of preserved historic detail, expansive three-level living, and an enchanting private garden, Residence 1 offers a distinctly Brooklyn living experience that is increasingly difficult to find.
Listing History for 557 Carlton Ave, 1
Now
10/26/2026
$9,500
Initial Rent by Jason Abrishami
Douglas Elliman
2026
Building Details for 557 Carlton Ave
OwnershipRental Property
Building TypeTownhouse
Service LevelVoice Intercom
AgePre-War
AccessWalk-up
Year Built1880
Floors/Apts3/2
Transit and Citi Bike
Subway
Bergen St
0.21 miles
7 Av
0.26 miles
Clinton-Washington Avs
0.33 miles
Grand Army Plaza
0.37 miles
Atlantic Av-Barclays Ctr
0.41 miles
Railroad
Atlantic TerminalLong Island Rail Road
0.32 miles
Citi Bike
Carlton Ave & Dean St
0.02 miles
Bergen St & Vanderbilt Ave
0.18 miles
Contact Agents
Contact Agents
Building Availability
Two Beds in Prospect Heights
Prospect Heights | Brooklyn
Quick Profile
Prospect Heights is a small residential neighborhood surrounded by big attractions. It’s rich in culture and offers the perfect blend of old Brooklyn charm and modern-day hipness.
Residents of this tight-knit community include young professionals, families and long-time residents. It’s a walkers paradise - just steps from Prospect Park and a short walking distance to neighborhoods like Downtown Brooklyn, Fort Green and Clinton. You’re close to culture too. Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn Library, Brooklyn Botanical Garden, Brooklyn Academy of Music and the Barclays Center are all nearby.
Prospect Heights is bordered by Flatbush Avenue to the west, Washington Avenue to the east, Atlantic Avenue and Dean Street to the north and Eastern Parkway to the south.
Prospect Heights, like many areas of New York City, was first inhabited by indigenous tribes and eventually settled by the Dutch and turned into farmland.
A significant part of the Revolutionary War was fought in Prospect Heights and the surrounding areas. Known as the Battle of Brooklyn, it was the first military engagement following the Declaration of Independence. Things didn’t go so well for American forces so they retreated and the British occupied Manhattan for several years after the Battle of Brooklyn.
In 1867, the opening of Prospect Park caused major housing growth in Prospect Heights. The middle-class neighborhood was soon populated by Jewish, Italian, and Irish workers. Many of which were shop-owners or employed as laborers in nearby factories.
Housing in Prospect Heights includes single-family row houses, historic townhouses, co-ops, and new luxury condos. The median listed price for a 1-bedroom in Prospect Heights is $680,000 with an average price per square foot is $944.
The neighborhood's commercial artery runs along Vanderbilt Avenue and Washington Avenue. The variety of businesses adds to the charm of the neighborhood. They include bars, pubs, restaurants and mom-and-pop stores of all types. The shops and eateries are a perfect alternative to the big-name attractions that bracket the neighborhood. It's a little bit of everything in this neighborhood.
Subways are plentiful in Prospect Heights. Its proximity to Manhattan is another perk of the neighborhood. It's about a half-hour train ride. The B, D, N, Q, R, 2, 3, 4 and 5 subway lines all serve the Atlantic Avenue/Barclays Center station. 2, 3, 4, B and Q trains cover the neighborhood and the A and C trains are nearby too.
All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
OLR ID: 202114
Find home. Discover happiness.